NJCAA D-I All-Region VI (25)
| Year | Player | Position |
| 1980 | Beth Gaughan | Guard |
| Linda Nelson | Guard | |
| 1981 | Beth Gaughan | Guard |
| Mary Michalski | Forward | |
| 1982 | Jana Talley | Guard |
| 1983 | Leslie Heeer | Forward |
| 1984 | Laurie Blackwell | Center |
| 1985 | Angela Kuehn | Forward |
| 1987 | Lisa Kirby | Guard |
| 1988 | Julie Blavier | Forward |
| Lisa Kirby | Guard | |
| 1989 | Darcy Bieber | Guard |
| Lori Heeter | Forward | |
| 1990 | Darcy Bieber | Guard |
| LaRon Fowler | Forward | |
| 1991 | Tonya Baucom | Center |
| 1992 | Cindy Bricker | Center |
| Melissa Grider | Guard | |
| Melissa Mashburn | Forward | |
| 1993 | Amy Brandsgaard | Forward |
| 1994 | Emily Mayo | Guard |
| Dennie Young | Center | |
| 1995 | Kirstin Folk | Forward |
| Emily Shopper | Forward | |
| 1997 | Beth Hinkebein |
NJCAA D-II All-Region VI (95)
| Year | Player | Position |
| 2001 | Somer Easterwood | Forward |
| Casey Ellis | Guard | |
| Lynsay Gallagher | Guard | |
| 2002 | Casey Ellis | Guard |
| Lynsay Gallagher | Guard | |
| Amber Lannan | Guard | |
| Gina Wheat | Guard | |
| 2003 | Andie Gurene | Forward |
| Laura Reeves | Guard | |
| Rachel Richard | Guard | |
| Kerri Vena | Guard | |
| 2004 | Liz Burks | Guard |
| Chelsea Campbell | Guard | |
| Amanda Koetting | Forward | |
| Laura Reeves | Guard | |
| 2005 | Alicia Baxte | Guard |
| Liz Burks | Guard | |
| Danielle Riekeberg | Center | |
| Emily Sherwood | Guard | |
| Krystal White | Forward | |
| 2006 | Alicia Baxter | Guard |
| Jodie Cochrane | Guard | |
| Katy Davenport | Center | |
| Shannon Howard | Forward | |
| Jacky Smith | Guard | |
| 2007 | Katy Davenport | Center |
| Heather Rourk | Forward | |
| Brittney Slifer | Guard | |
| Jacky Smith | Guard | |
| 2008 | Heather Rourk | Forward |
| Bethany Schwab | Guard | |
| Brittney Slifer | Guard | |
| Meghan Waggoner | Forward | |
| 2009 | Melissa Nelson | Guard |
| Danielle Shows | Forward | |
| 2010 | Crista Bechard | Guard |
| Taylor Bird | Forward | |
| Emily Blakesley | Guard | |
| Emily Nelson | Guard | |
| Liz Smith | Center | |
| 2011 | Taylor Bird | Forward |
| Tanchelle Hollingsworth | Guard | |
| Liz Smith | Center | |
| Mary Pat Specht | Guard | |
| 2012 | Polly Harrington | Forward |
| Ameishia Kearney | Forward | |
| Brianna Kulas | Forward | |
| Mary Pat Specht | Guard | |
| 2013 | Kathleen Brisbane | Forward |
| DaShawn Harden | Guard | |
| Timeka O'Neal | Guard | |
| Juanita Robinson | Guard | |
| 2014 | Kariel Hutt | Center |
| Sameia Kendall | Guard | |
| Timeka O'Neal | Guard | |
| Juanita Robinson | Guard | |
| Nieka Wheeler | Forward | |
| 2015 | Aleix Brown | Guard |
| Nieka Wheeler | Forward | |
| 2016 | Chastity Franklin | Guard |
| Bh'rea Griffin | Guard | |
| Kayonna Lee | Forward | |
| Erica Nelson | Guard | |
| 2017 | Kyessence Collins | Guard |
| Kierra Isaiah | Forward | |
| Arielle Jackson | Guard | |
| Austin Richardson | Forward | |
| 2018 | Paige Elston | Guard |
| Tristen McFeders | Guard | |
| Cerena Reeves | Forward | |
| 2019 | Paige Elston | Guard |
| Jaci Stowers | Forward | |
| 2020 | KK Jackson-Morris | Forward |
| Krystal Rice | Guard | |
| 2021 | Presley Barton | Guard |
| LaJahda Boyland | Forward | |
| Gabby Fuller | Guard | |
| Jaylen Townsend | Guard | |
| 2022 | Gabby Fuller | Guard |
| Mackenzie Hart | Guard | |
| Kierra Prim | Guard | |
| Nariyah Simmons | Guard | |
| Jaylen Townsend | Guard | |
| 2023 | Mackenzie Hart | Guard |
| Nariyah Simmons | Guard | |
| Lisa Thomas | Guard | |
| 2024 | Saige Grampsas | Guard |
| Jazzy Klinge | Guard | |
| Taliyah Scott | Guard | |
| Amani Henry | Forward |